Turkish Coalition of America on Twitter Turkish Coalition of America on Facebook Turkish Coalition of America on YouTube
Turkish Coalition of America
  • Amerika Turk Koalisyonu

The International Politics of Armenian History

The International Politics of Armenian History

In addition to asking how one feels about what happened to many innocent Armenians in Anatolia during World War I, one might find it an interesting and cerebral exercise to ask: Why is the history of these events immersed in political controversy to this day, especially on April 24?

Edward A. Freeman, who was appointed at the recommendation of Prime Minister Gladstone to chair the University of Oxford's prestigious Regius Professorship of Modern History in the late 19th century, famously announced it as true "that history is past politics and that politics are but present history."He embodied both history and politics. While Freeman failed in his three political bids for parliament, as a historian he was the progenitor for a long line of Turcophobic historians and politicians in Britain, including James Bryce and Arnold J. Toynbee, authors of the wartime propaganda that serves as the basis for the Armenian narrative today.

Freeman taught that "the Turk and the Jew are leagued against the Christian," and that Europe is "the common possession of Aryan blood and speech." He tirelessly incited all Ottoman Christians to rebel against the Turks whom he considered to be strangers in Europe and unfit to rule, and proclaimed that "every nation has a right to get rid of strangers who prove a nuisance, whether they are Chinese in America, or Jews in Russia, Serbia, Hungary, and Romania." Freeman also held the conviction that America would be a better place "if every Irishman should kill a negro and be hanged for it."This is the man who intensified the calls for "the Turkish horde" to be "driven back to its native deserts, or else die out" in the 1860s, before inspiring Gladstone's Bulgarian Agitation and, yes, before tutoring Bryce into first problematizing the Ottoman Armenian condition in 1876.

To a great extent, Freeman, whose influence is vastly understudied, is responsible for the fact that the Armenian issue, as a subplot of Britain's Eastern Question, was fated to be a case of politicized history.However, when considering the current map of international politics, why is the history of the Armenian tragedy still politicized rather than remembered?

For Britain, the unraveling of the Armenian narrative would mean an embarrassing review of a British historiography that is based on interpersonal ties to Liberal leaders, unchecked prejudice, and the pretense of "moral" imperialism. A long list of revered politicians, scientists and historians in the late Victorian era would have to be viewed in a different light in order to fully contextualize the spirit of anti-Semitism and Turcophobia among the Liberal opposition during Benjamin Disraeli's premiership from 1874 to 1880. Understanding why certain Armenian representatives in Europe were empowered to perpetuate conflict with the Ottoman state and jeopardize the lives of many Armenian communities in Anatolia would necessarily cast a dark shadow on the memory of Gladstone, who was elected to lead Britain's government more times than any other in the kingdom's history. Moreover, an examination of the Armenian narrative would not only call into question the accuracy of Britain's wartime reports but reveal a clear British motivation to organize Armenian rebellion in World War I for the very purpose of having it result in bloodshed and effective propaganda.

For France, the position on the Armenian narrative is mainly dictated by the political commitment to please an Armenian population that is largely concentrated in certain electoral districts, and this has led to a draconian bill that was designed to force the public into accepting a biased narration of history.For instance, it is no coincidence that the main supporters of the notorious genocide bill represent Armenian constituents, be it Valérie Boyer of Bouches-du-Rhône in the National Assembly (2011) or Hervé Marseille of Hauts-de-Seine in the Senate (2012). Passing such a bill is tantamount to robbing Turks of the freedom to speak about their own history, all because of French domestic politics.

For the EU, the demand that Turkey should recognize the Armenian tragedy as genocide is one of several political options through which Brussels may deny Turkish membership and still make it seem as if it is Turkey's own doing. Thus, Turkey will be made to appear as stubborn and non-cooperative while certain European governments will continue to harbor their Islamophobic denial of Turkish progress.
In truth, had there not been an Armenian issue, there likely would have been another European pretext to block Turkey out of Europe.

For Russia, the politicization of the Armenian narrative is an indirect manner of dancing around the next round of cold-warring with the West. As evidenced by Russia, Today, a TV news network owned by Russia, and The Independent, a London newspaper owned by a Russian, the Armenian issue seems to resurface every time there is need to harass Turkey in hope of disrupting its NATO alliance with the West and tilting the balance of power in the Middle East.

For the U.S., when considering Turkey's pivotal role in several regions, the Armenian issue is a leverage better kept than discarded. In this fashion, the U.S. is balancing a convenient push and pull:Turkey's compliance with American interests is procured by both incentives and pressures. While there are plenty of carrots in U.S.-Turkey relations, the Armenian issue is one clear stick that the U.S. is waving at Turkey. This is achieved by the constant threat of officially labeling the Armenian tragedy as genocide in Congress or the U.N. It should seem odd that in the U.S. more scholars and politicians talk about genocide in the Armenian context than in the context of both slavery and America's indigenous population; it would only be odd if politics were not involved. Throughout this practice, Turkey is made to appear as if it was "saved" by the White House from the ramifications of international condemnation that a genocide label entails. Along these lines, it is made to appear as if the Turks are taking advantage of American pragmatic considerations of foreign policy, and as if the reason to support genocide labeling is a moral one.

For the genocide industry, the labeling of the Armenian tragedy as genocide is a matter of life and death: If the Armenians did not suffer a genocide, then many genocide scholars would be unemployed.These centers and organizations, which are dedicated to "genociding" most cases of mass deaths from famine to tsunami, may have the appearance of nonstate actors but are closely aligned with the interests of state institutions. They are programed to deny the uniqueness of the Holocaust in order to weaken Turkey's position in the international political system.For Armenia, the genocide narrative is the foundation of its obsession with playing the role of victim.Since the 1990s, the constant networking to associate Armenians with suffering has had the deliberate effect of diminishing the level of international criticism on Armenia's vicious annexation of Nagorno-Karabakh and the displacement of nearly one million Azeris. In other words, for Armenia to successfully cover up its offenses against Azerbaijan it has been enough to keep parading the genocide claims as a symbol of Armenian victimhood without even having to prove that what happened in World War I corresponds with the U.N. definition of genocide.Sadly, as in the days of Armenian rebellion against the Ottoman state, decisions that affect the common Armenian in the Caucasus are made by the diasporic Armenians of power and wealth. For the Armenian Americans, the genocide extravaganza is not only a source of identity, but the source of their political participation and relevance in Washington, D.C.

And for Turkey? Why are there calls for genocide recognition in Turkey? Many Turkish scholars and journalists, who continuously search for opportunities to showcase their Euro-lust, hear the persisting calls against their Ottoman predecessors and jump on the genocide bandwagon. Their wish to be accepted by Western intellectuals, in keeping with their imagined society, has led them to choose the cheap semblance of liberalism over the study of facts and the demonstration of loyalty to their own people's history. Should the quest for European acceptance mean that Turkey has to accept lies and derision? Truly progressive intellectuality would have the Turk debate other Europeans, equal among equals, historiography to historiography, rather than yield to political dictations of history.

* PhD candidate, University of Utah

Daily Sabah; April 29, 2014

  • Post this article to Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Print this page

List of Articles on the Turkish-Armenian Question

  • The Turkish Armenian Historical Controversy: How to Name the Events of 1915The Turkish Armenian Historical Controversy: How to Name the Events of 1915read more
  • Lord Curzon’s exasperation towards the ethnic cleansing policy carried out by ArmeniaLord Curzon’s exasperation towards the ethnic cleansing policy carried out bread more
  • The Armenian Forced Relocation: Putting An End To Misleading SimplificationsThe Armenian Forced Relocation: Putting An End To Misleading Simplificationsread more
  • “Proving” a “Crime against Humanity”?“Proving” a “Crime against Humanity”?read more
  • A Bad Day In The BundestagA Bad Day In The BundestagJeremy Salt, Center For Eurasian Studies...read more
  • Not recognizing the Armenian genocide is a triumph for common senseNot recognizing the Armenian genocide is a triumph for common senseread more
  • The fallacies of the Armenian nationalist narrativeThe fallacies of the Armenian nationalist narrativeread more
  • Perincek vs SwitzerlandPerincek vs SwitzerlandFreedom of expression has already won th...read more
  • The Accusation of GenocideThe Accusation of Genocide...read more
  • Armenian Issue As Reflected In Russian Archival RecordsArmenian Issue As Reflected In Russian Archival Recordsread more
  • Armenia should constructively consider PM's proposalArmenia should constructively consider PM's proposalread more
  • The Lemkin Hole In The Swiss CaseThe Lemkin Hole In The Swiss CaseWhen Raphael Lemkin coined the word geno...read more
  • The International Politics of Armenian HistoryThe International Politics of Armenian Historyread more
  • Abraham Foxman’s good nameAbraham Foxman’s good nameIt is shocking that Abraham Foxman, the ...read more
  • Remembering Kemal Arikan (1927-1982)Remembering Kemal Arikan (1927-1982)On January 28, 1982 two Armenian gunmen ...read more
  • Orientalism: 'Terrible Turk' becomes a 'genocidal Turk'Orientalism: 'Terrible Turk' becomes a 'genocidal Turk'read more
  • TCA Responds to President Obama’s Armenian Remembrance Day StatementTCA Responds to President Obama’s Armenian Remembrance Day Statementread more
  • Religious Ceremony Held at Historical Armenian Church in TurkeyReligious Ceremony Held at Historical Armenian Church in Turkeyread more
  • Armenian President's Belligerent Remarks Draw Turkey’s IreArmenian President's Belligerent Remarks Draw Turkey’s Ireread more
  • TCA Response to President Obama's StatementTCA Response to President Obama's Statementread more
  • Why Congress Should Not Legislate HistoryWhy Congress Should Not Legislate HistoryMichael M. Gunter, April 8, 2011 On M...read more
  • Armenians in Ottoman BureaucracyArmenians in Ottoman BureaucracyArmenians held key positions in Ottoman ...read more
  • Tarihsel Gerçekler ve Uluslararası Hukuk Işığında Ermeni Soykırımı İddiasıTarihsel Gerçekler ve Uluslararası Hukuk Işığında Ermeni Soykırımı İread more
  • Amb. Elekdağ Calls Upon President Obama to Respect Law on GenocideAmb. Elekdağ Calls Upon President Obama to Respect Law on Genocideread more
  • Legislating HistoryLegislating HistoryYilmaz Arguden, October 24, 2006 Rece...read more
  • President Obama's StatementPresident Obama's StatementApril 24, 2009, Washington, DC - Preside...read more
  • 154 Retired Turkish Ambassadors Write to Speaker Pelosi 154 Retired Turkish Ambassadors Write to Speaker Pelosi read more
  • Will Untapped Ottoman Archives Reshape the Armenian Debate?Will Untapped Ottoman Archives Reshape the Armenian Debate?read more
  • Rep. Frank Pallone and the "Armenian Genocide Resolution"Rep. Frank Pallone and the "Armenian Genocide Resolution"read more
  • Professor questions ethnic conflictProfessor questions ethnic conflictMatthew Rist, The GW Hatchet, February 2...read more
  • Money spent by the Armenian Lobby in America (USA/ Armenia)Money spent by the Armenian Lobby in America (USA/ Armenia)read more
  • Buying PoliciesBuying PoliciesMichael van der Galien, PoliGazette, Aug...read more
  • The freedom of historical debate is under attack by the memory policeThe freedom of historical debate is under attack by the memory policeread more
  • Book review: The Armenian Genocide: Cultural and Ethical LegaciesBook review: The Armenian Genocide: Cultural and Ethical Legaciesread more
  • U.S. H.RES. 106: Factual and Legal DeficienciesU.S. H.RES. 106: Factual and Legal Deficienciesread more
  • A Scrutiny of Akcam's Version of History and the Armenian GenocideA Scrutiny of Akcam's Version of History and the Armenian Genocideread more
  • Turkish Armenian RelationsTurkish Armenian RelationsNursen Mazici, Radikal Daily, June 30, 2...read more
  • Armenia is a troubled nationArmenia is a troubled nationJason Epstein, Pajamas Media, April 24, ...read more
  • Armenian Terrorism: History as Poison and AntidoteArmenian Terrorism: History as Poison and Antidoteread more
  • Reader comment on: "Lévy To Speak On Islamism, Genocide"Reader comment on: "Lévy To Speak On Islamism, Genocide"read more
  • The History LessonThe History LessonNational Review Online, October 17, 2007...read more
  • Westerners on the Armenian Strategy and RebellionWesterners on the Armenian Strategy and Rebellionread more
  • Report of Captian Niles and Mr. Arthur E. Sutherland Jr.Report of Captian Niles and Mr. Arthur E. Sutherland Jr.read more
  • ADL and the TurksADL and the TurksJoel J. Sprayregen Chicago, The Jerusale...read more
  • No Armenian GenocideNo Armenian GenocideBernard Lewis, National Press Club, Augu...read more
  • Bernard Lewis Distinguishes Armenian Case from HolocaustBernard Lewis Distinguishes Armenian Case from Holocaustread more
  • Anatolia 1915:Turks Died, TooAnatolia 1915:Turks Died, TooJustin McCarthy, The Boston Globe, April...read more
  • Let Historians Decide on So-called GenocideLet Historians Decide on So-called Genocideread more
  • Turkey's new envoy says genocide bill impedes reconciliationTurkey's new envoy says genocide bill impedes reconciliationread more
  • Turkey's War on the TruthTurkey's War on the TruthRichard Cohen, Washington Post, October ...read more
  • Partisan Politics and Democrats' Turkey ProblemPartisan Politics and Democrats' Turkey Problemread more
  • Why We Are Losing TurkeyWhy We Are Losing TurkeyTony Blankley Real Clear Politics, Octob...read more
  • Genocide claims against Turkey frivolousGenocide claims against Turkey frivolousThomas Goltz Missoulian News Online, Oct...read more
  • Congress and ArmeniaCongress and ArmeniaTayyip Erdogan, PM of Turkey, The Wall S...read more
  • Armenian genocide measure is misguidedArmenian genocide measure is misguidedBruce Fein, San Francisco Chronicle, Oct...read more
  • Armenian debacleArmenian debacleTulin Daloglu, Washington Times, October...read more
  • History Speaks: The moral case against the Armenian Genocide ResolutionHistory Speaks: The moral case against the Armenian Genocide Resolutionread more
  • Judgment Time: Should America recognize an Armenian Genocide?Judgment Time: Should America recognize an Armenian Genocide?read more
  • Armenian Story has Another SideArmenian Story has Another SideNorman Stone,Chicago Tribune, October 16...read more
  • U.S. can calm a ruffled TurkeyU.S. can calm a ruffled TurkeyThe Christian Monitor, October 17, 2007 ...read more
  • Pointless Moral Exhibitionism on TurkeyPointless Moral Exhibitionism on TurkeyRich Lowry,The National Review, October ...read more
  • Stirring up the past, jeopardizing the futureStirring up the past, jeopardizing the futureread more
  • Armenia Crime Amnesia?Armenia Crime Amnesia?Bruce Fein, The Washington Times, Oct 16...read more
  • Secretary of State PelosiSecretary of State PelosiThe Wall Street Journal, October 16, 200...read more
  • Turkey in the crosshairsTurkey in the crosshairsThe Washington Times, October 15, 2007 ...read more
  • Tawdry Genocide TaleTawdry Genocide TaleBruce Fein, Washington Times, September ...read more
  • This wasn't GenocideThis wasn't GenocideShlomo Bar-Meir, Jerusalem Post, Septemb...read more
  • Letter to Abraham H. Foxman, ADL of B'Nai B'RithLetter to Abraham H. Foxman, ADL of B'Nai B'Rithread more
  • Why America Should Build Bridges to TurkeyWhy America Should Build Bridges to TurkeyLiz Peek, July 3, 2007 The Turks are...read more
  • Statement by Professor Norman StoneStatement by Professor Norman StoneNorman Stone, August 23, 2007 I am wr...read more
  • Re: Truth and Consequences: Armenians, Turks and JewsRe: Truth and Consequences: Armenians, Turks and Jewsread more
  • Let's Unearth the Truth About what happened in 1915 togetherLet's Unearth the Truth About what happened in 1915 togetherread more
  • Turkish ambassador: "Give all sides a hearing"Turkish ambassador: "Give all sides a hearing"read more
  • Judgment Time:Should America recognize an Armenian Genocide?Judgment Time:Should America recognize an Armenian Genocide?read more
  • Norman Stone: 'There is No Armenian Genocide'Norman Stone: 'There is No Armenian Genocide'read more
  • New Scholarship Disputes Armenian New Scholarship Disputes Armenian "Genocide" Narrativeread more
  • Home
  • About US
  • Support TCA
  • Contact
  • Internships
    • TCA Washington Summer Internship Program
    • Previous Programs
  • Youth Congress
    • 2019 Youth Congress Application
    • 2018 Youth Congress
    • 2017 Youth Congress
    • 2016 Youth Congress
    • 2015 Youth Congress
    • 2014 Youth Congress
    • Turkish-Canadian Youth Congress
  • Turkish American Women’s Leadership Initiative
  • Grants
    • Turkey Study Tour Grants
    • Academic Grants
    • Public Awareness / Grassroots Grants
    • Heritage Grants
    • Humanitarian Grants
  • Issues & Information
    • U.S.-Turkey Relations
    • PKK Terrorism
    • Turkey and Europe
    • Armenian Issue
    • Cyprus Issue
    • Turkish History
    • Turkish Minorities Abroad
    • TCA Issue Papers
    • Reading Lists and General Resources on Turkey
  • Turkish American Community
    • Turkish American Appointed Officials
    • Turkish Americans Elected to Political Office
    • Elected Officials with Turkish Heritage
    • Turkish American Organizations
    • Turkish American Publications and Broadcasts
    • Turkish American Online Services
    • Prominent Turkish Americans
    • Turk Evleri
  • U.S. Congress
  • The Turkey Caucus
  • Outreach to Heritage Communities
    • African American Outreach
    • Native American Outreach
    • Hispanic American Outreach
  • Scholarships
    • Study Abroad Scholarships for American Students of Minority and Heritage Communities
    • Scholarships by Other Organizations
    • Previous TCA Programs
  • News & Events
    • News and Events
    • TCA Issue Papers
    • TCA Newsletters
  • Media
    • TCA in the News
    • Posters and Advertisements
    • Submit a Media Request
  • TAKE ACTION
  • LEGAL RIGHTS
  • CULTURE
Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Donate
  • Support the Turkish Coalition of America by Shopping at AmazonSmile
  • Turkish Coalition of America on YouTube
Turkish Coalition of America
Amerika Turk Koalisyonu
  • Boston
    P.O. Box 611
    Bedford, MA 01730
    Phone: 978.318.0047
    Fax: 978.318.0037
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  • Copyright © 2023 Turkish Coalition of America. All rights reserved.
    Site Map