Turkish Coalition of America on Twitter Turkish Coalition of America on Facebook Turkish Coalition of America on YouTube
Turkish Coalition of America
  • Amerika Turk Koalisyonu

Armenia should constructively consider PM's proposal

Ministers applaud Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, front, at the Parliament in Ankara on Wednesday, April 23. (Photo: AP)
Ministers applaud Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, front, at the Parliament in Ankara on Wednesday, April 23. (Photo: AP)

It also shows that Turkey is not shunning the truth and is not afraid of confronting its past. That was evidenced in his remarks: “… we wish that the Armenians who lost their lives in the context of the early 20th century rest in peace, and we convey our condolences to their grandchildren. Regardless of their ethnic or religious origins, we pay tribute, with compassion and respect, to all Ottoman citizens who lost their lives in the same period and under similar conditions.” However, his statement should not be taken as a step toward recognition of the Armenian allegations and a concession; nor should it be viewed as a unilateral apology.

The functional side of the full statement is that the conditions for the aspired-to peace and reconciliation between the parties are clearly laid out. These conditions include the establishment of a joint historical commission by the parties to reveal the facts of the 1915 incidents and analyze the findings in light of the applicable legal framework. The decision of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) on the Doğu Perinçek case, which rejected “the existence of a general consensus” on the Armenian genocide allegation and maintained that this is a controversial issue, allowed Ankara to adopt a bold initiative for peace with Yerevan.

Parliament's declaration for the formation of a joint historical inquiry

The prime minister's expression of regret for the lives lost by Armenians and other Ottoman people in the conditions that prevailed during the period of 1915 is another striking part of the statement. As for the humane approach in the statement, we should note that Parliament also adopted the same approach in a declaration unanimously adopted on April 13, 2005. The declaration extended a hand of peace and amity to Armenia and referred to the following justifications for the establishment of a joint historical commission.

“The Parliament believes that both Turkey's and Armenia's interests are best served in the reconciliation of the Turkish and Armenian peoples, who lived in peace and mutual tolerance for centuries on the same land, to save them from being hostage to deep prejudices stemming from the war years, and in the creation of an environment that will enable them to share a common future based on tolerance, friendship and cooperation.

“The government and the opposition parties have made a proposal to that end, which aims to shed light on historical facts through scientific research so as to prevent history from continuing to be a burden for these two nations. By this move they have proposed to establish a joint commission by Turkey and Armenia composed of historians from both sides, to open their national archives without any restrictions to research and to disclose the findings of this research to world public opinion. The proposal further specifies that the commission can carry on its research in the archives of other related countries and that the parties will determine the establishment and working methods of said commission.

"The Parliament fully supports and approves this historic proposal. The cooperation of the government of Armenia is a must for the implementation of this initiative. To this end, unless Turkey and Armenia rely on a common perspective on historical facts, the inheritance that both sides will leave to their children and future generations will be nothing other than biases, enmity and sentiments of revenge.

"Wisdom and logic command Turkey and Armenia not to be afraid of destroying taboos and to face their history by discovering all the aspects of the human tragedy they experienced together. This is the way to prevent the past from overshadowing our present and future.

The Parliament underlines the fact that the proposal of the Turkish Republic should be considered, in essence, an initiative for peace. If Armenia wants to establish good neighborly relations with Turkey and develop a basis for cooperation, it should not hesitate to accept Turkey's proposal for a joint historical evaluation.”

Diaspora's attitude

The positive impression generated by Turkey's bold and peaceful initiative to set up a joint historical commission in the international arena should be underlined. This impression is confirmed by the joint declaration of 97 parliamentarians from the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE), the decision by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) and the remarks by former German Chancellor Gerhard Schröder and American Ambassador to Turkey Francis Ricciardone that the establishment of a joint commission would contribute to the achievement of reconciliation between the Turkish and Armenian nations.

The Armenian diaspora strongly opposed Turkey's proposal for the establishment of a joint commission, as it would undermine the credibility of their allegations. For this reason, the provision on the creation of a joint commission, which has been strongly supported and promoted by Turkey, was the main issue during the deliberations on the twin protocols signed on Oct. 10, 2009 in Zurich by the Turkish and Armenian foreign ministers. This provision has also played an important role in the obstruction of the ratification of the protocols as well, because nationalist and militant Armenians as well as the diaspora fiercely opposed this proposal, asserting that the Armenian genocide is a historically established fact not open to further research and negotiation.

ECtHR: Genocide allegation is controversial

In light of this antagonistic stance, one is inclined to ask what sort of development took place that accounts for the Turkish side's hope that its proposal for the establishment of a joint commission might be practically viable.

This development is the ECtHR judgment in the Perinçek case. Swiss courts had convicted Perinçek over his remarks that the Armenian genocide allegation was a lie, basing their decisions on the contention that there exists “a general consensus concerning the legal characterization of the events in question as genocide.” But the European court, in its judgment on Dec. 17, 2013, rejected the Swiss courts' view and stressed that the Armenian genocide allegation was controversial for three reasons.

First, it pointed out that it would be very difficult to identify a general consensus, as there were differing views even among the Swiss political organs themselves. The Swiss Federal Court itself had acknowledged that there was no unanimity in the community as a whole concerning the legal categorization in question. Furthermore, only about 20 states out of 190 worldwide had officially recognized the Armenian genocide, and such recognition had not always been extended by the governments of those states but from their parliaments, as was the case in Switzerland.

Second, the court rightly recalled that the notion of “genocide” is a precisely defined legal concept. According to the case law of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, “genocide” requires that the acts in question must have been perpetrated with the specific intent to destroy not only certain members of the group but all or part of the group itself (dolus specialis). As a result the court, noting that genocide is a very narrow, difficult-to-prove legal concept, stated that it was not convinced that the “general consensus” on the existence of the Armenian genocide to which the courts of Switzerland referred in convicting Perinçek was consistent with such very specific points of law.

Third, the court expressed doubts on whether there could be a “general consensus” on events such as those at issue here, given that historical research was by definition open to discussion and a matter of debate, without necessarily giving rise to final conclusions or to the assertion of objective and absolute truths. In this connection, the court's underlining the fact that Armenian claims cannot be compared to the Holocaust, clearly distinguishes the case from those concerning the denial of the crimes of the Holocaust committed by the Nazi regime, as those crimes have a clear legal basis established and proven by an international court.

Outcome of appeal is doubtful

As can be seen from the above, the ECtHR rejected the Swiss court's assertion that the Armenian genocide is a matter of “general historical and scientific consensus” whose existence had to be considered established as a matter of fact and could not be challenged in court -- even though the issue had not been adjudicated by a competent judicial authority. The court also set aside any contention of legal equivalence of the “Armenian genocide” with the Holocaust, since there had been a clear legal basis for the recognition of the Holocaust as genocide. The Holocaust was unambiguously established as fact and defined as a crime by the International Military Tribunal at Nuremberg, whereas no such valid judicial finding has so far been made in respect to the Armenian situation.

Switzerland decided to appeal the ECtHR ruling on the Perinçek case. The Swiss Federal Office of Justice announced on March 11, 2014 that the ECtHR's Grand Chamber will be requested to review the ruling in order to clarify the scope available to the Swiss authorities in applying Swiss criminal law to combat racism. However, the appeal for review remains pretty weak, because it does not offer new findings or arguments. Furthermore, it is really a remote possibility that the Grand Chamber will challenge the above-mentioned three arguments that the court's judgment is based upon.

In the light of these newly emergent conditions, the diaspora and Armenia need to switch to a more realistic approach vis-à-vis Turkey's proposal suggesting the establishment of a joint commission.

Government's acceptance of my proposal for creation of a joint commission

I have been proposing the establishment of a joint historical commission between Turkey and Armenia since the 2000s, in my talks with high-ranking officials of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs; however, arguing that this is a fairly risky move, they did not adopt this proposal. I have continued to subscribe to this view since being elected as a Republican People's Party (CHP) deputy in the elections on Nov. 3, 2002. Following several meetings with then-Foreign Minister Abdullah Gül, he, despite objection by the ministry bureaucracy, concurred that this was a fair, constructive and humane approach and that it would take Turkey to a better position in the dispute. Most important, he persuaded Prime Minister Erdoğan that this project was an appropriate initiative. I also got the approval of then-CHP Chairman Deniz Baykal on this matter. The proposal thus resulted in a sort of miracle, as it brought together the Prime Minister and the chairman of the main opposition party, who were not on very good terms, for a meeting in the office of the Prime Minister at Parliament on March 8, 2008. The Prime Minister reviewed the proposal, but he still had some questions in mind. Subsequent to my briefing, in a joint press conference, Erdoğan and Baykal announced the proposal to establish a joint historical commission in the context of the peace initiative vis-a-vis Armenia. With this initiative, they demonstrated that Turkey is not afraid to confront its past and that they expected the same attitude from Armenia in the name of peace and friendship. The Parliament unanimously adopted this proposal on April 13, 2005.

What wisdom and reason require

Armenia should positively consider this initiative launched by Prime Minister Erdoğan in order to extract Turkish-Armenian relations from where they have been stuck for 99 years.

Unless this is done, it will not be possible to free Armenians from a consuming preoccupation with victimization and usurpation and Turks from the feeling of being the unfair target of a worldwide conspiracy of calumny and slander. And in that case, it would be a fantasy to suppose that these two nations could ever achieve reconciliation and peace.

For this reason, a contemporary approach based on wisdom and reason must be achieved by exposing all aspects of the human tragedy that befell Turks and Armenians to daylight and by confronting the historical facts and accepting them. Peace will inevitably be born out of this trauma.

*Dr. Şükrü Elekdağ is a retired ambassador, former undersecretary of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and former deputy for the Republican People's Party

Today's Zaman, June 02, 2014

  • Post this article to Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Print this page

List of Articles on the Turkish-Armenian Question

  • Miatsum and the Bewildering Russian Role in KarabakhMiatsum and the Bewildering Russian Role in Karabakhread more
  • The Turkish Armenian Historical Controversy: How to Name the Events of 1915The Turkish Armenian Historical Controversy: How to Name the Events of 1915read more
  • Lord Curzon’s exasperation towards the ethnic cleansing policy carried out by ArmeniaLord Curzon’s exasperation towards the ethnic cleansing policy carried out bread more
  • The Armenian Forced Relocation: Putting An End To Misleading SimplificationsThe Armenian Forced Relocation: Putting An End To Misleading Simplificationsread more
  • “Proving” a “Crime against Humanity”?“Proving” a “Crime against Humanity”?read more
  • A Bad Day In The BundestagA Bad Day In The BundestagJeremy Salt, Center For Eurasian Studies...read more
  • Not recognizing the Armenian genocide is a triumph for common senseNot recognizing the Armenian genocide is a triumph for common senseread more
  • The fallacies of the Armenian nationalist narrativeThe fallacies of the Armenian nationalist narrativeread more
  • Perincek vs SwitzerlandPerincek vs SwitzerlandFreedom of expression has already won th...read more
  • The Accusation of GenocideThe Accusation of Genocide...read more
  • Armenian Issue As Reflected In Russian Archival RecordsArmenian Issue As Reflected In Russian Archival Recordsread more
  • Armenia should constructively consider PM's proposalArmenia should constructively consider PM's proposalread more
  • The Lemkin Hole In The Swiss CaseThe Lemkin Hole In The Swiss CaseWhen Raphael Lemkin coined the word geno...read more
  • The International Politics of Armenian HistoryThe International Politics of Armenian Historyread more
  • Abraham Foxman’s good nameAbraham Foxman’s good nameIt is shocking that Abraham Foxman, the ...read more
  • Remembering Kemal Arikan (1927-1982)Remembering Kemal Arikan (1927-1982)On January 28, 1982 two Armenian gunmen ...read more
  • Orientalism: 'Terrible Turk' becomes a 'genocidal Turk'Orientalism: 'Terrible Turk' becomes a 'genocidal Turk'read more
  • TCA Responds to President Obama’s Armenian Remembrance Day StatementTCA Responds to President Obama’s Armenian Remembrance Day Statementread more
  • Religious Ceremony Held at Historical Armenian Church in TurkeyReligious Ceremony Held at Historical Armenian Church in Turkeyread more
  • Armenian President's Belligerent Remarks Draw Turkey’s IreArmenian President's Belligerent Remarks Draw Turkey’s Ireread more
  • TCA Response to President Obama's StatementTCA Response to President Obama's Statementread more
  • Why Congress Should Not Legislate HistoryWhy Congress Should Not Legislate HistoryMichael M. Gunter, April 8, 2011 On M...read more
  • Armenians in Ottoman BureaucracyArmenians in Ottoman BureaucracyArmenians held key positions in Ottoman ...read more
  • Tarihsel Gerçekler ve Uluslararası Hukuk Işığında Ermeni Soykırımı İddiasıTarihsel Gerçekler ve Uluslararası Hukuk Işığında Ermeni Soykırımı İread more
  • Amb. Elekdağ Calls Upon President Obama to Respect Law on GenocideAmb. Elekdağ Calls Upon President Obama to Respect Law on Genocideread more
  • Legislating HistoryLegislating HistoryYilmaz Arguden, October 24, 2006 Rece...read more
  • President Obama's StatementPresident Obama's StatementApril 24, 2009, Washington, DC - Preside...read more
  • 154 Retired Turkish Ambassadors Write to Speaker Pelosi 154 Retired Turkish Ambassadors Write to Speaker Pelosi read more
  • Will Untapped Ottoman Archives Reshape the Armenian Debate?Will Untapped Ottoman Archives Reshape the Armenian Debate?read more
  • Rep. Frank Pallone and the "Armenian Genocide Resolution"Rep. Frank Pallone and the "Armenian Genocide Resolution"read more
  • Professor questions ethnic conflictProfessor questions ethnic conflictMatthew Rist, The GW Hatchet, February 2...read more
  • Money spent by the Armenian Lobby in America (USA/ Armenia)Money spent by the Armenian Lobby in America (USA/ Armenia)read more
  • Buying PoliciesBuying PoliciesMichael van der Galien, PoliGazette, Aug...read more
  • The freedom of historical debate is under attack by the memory policeThe freedom of historical debate is under attack by the memory policeread more
  • Book review: The Armenian Genocide: Cultural and Ethical LegaciesBook review: The Armenian Genocide: Cultural and Ethical Legaciesread more
  • U.S. H.RES. 106: Factual and Legal DeficienciesU.S. H.RES. 106: Factual and Legal Deficienciesread more
  • A Scrutiny of Akcam's Version of History and the Armenian GenocideA Scrutiny of Akcam's Version of History and the Armenian Genocideread more
  • Turkish Armenian RelationsTurkish Armenian RelationsNursen Mazici, Radikal Daily, June 30, 2...read more
  • Armenia is a troubled nationArmenia is a troubled nationJason Epstein, Pajamas Media, April 24, ...read more
  • Armenian Terrorism: History as Poison and AntidoteArmenian Terrorism: History as Poison and Antidoteread more
  • Reader comment on: "Lévy To Speak On Islamism, Genocide"Reader comment on: "Lévy To Speak On Islamism, Genocide"read more
  • The History LessonThe History LessonNational Review Online, October 17, 2007...read more
  • Westerners on the Armenian Strategy and RebellionWesterners on the Armenian Strategy and Rebellionread more
  • Report of Captian Niles and Mr. Arthur E. Sutherland Jr.Report of Captian Niles and Mr. Arthur E. Sutherland Jr.read more
  • ADL and the TurksADL and the TurksJoel J. Sprayregen Chicago, The Jerusale...read more
  • No Armenian GenocideNo Armenian GenocideBernard Lewis, National Press Club, Augu...read more
  • Bernard Lewis Distinguishes Armenian Case from HolocaustBernard Lewis Distinguishes Armenian Case from Holocaustread more
  • Anatolia 1915:Turks Died, TooAnatolia 1915:Turks Died, TooJustin McCarthy, The Boston Globe, April...read more
  • Let Historians Decide on So-called GenocideLet Historians Decide on So-called Genocideread more
  • Turkey's new envoy says genocide bill impedes reconciliationTurkey's new envoy says genocide bill impedes reconciliationread more
  • Turkey's War on the TruthTurkey's War on the TruthRichard Cohen, Washington Post, October ...read more
  • Partisan Politics and Democrats' Turkey ProblemPartisan Politics and Democrats' Turkey Problemread more
  • Why We Are Losing TurkeyWhy We Are Losing TurkeyTony Blankley Real Clear Politics, Octob...read more
  • Genocide claims against Turkey frivolousGenocide claims against Turkey frivolousThomas Goltz Missoulian News Online, Oct...read more
  • Congress and ArmeniaCongress and ArmeniaTayyip Erdogan, PM of Turkey, The Wall S...read more
  • Armenian genocide measure is misguidedArmenian genocide measure is misguidedBruce Fein, San Francisco Chronicle, Oct...read more
  • Armenian debacleArmenian debacleTulin Daloglu, Washington Times, October...read more
  • History Speaks: The moral case against the Armenian Genocide ResolutionHistory Speaks: The moral case against the Armenian Genocide Resolutionread more
  • Judgment Time: Should America recognize an Armenian Genocide?Judgment Time: Should America recognize an Armenian Genocide?read more
  • Armenian Story has Another SideArmenian Story has Another SideNorman Stone,Chicago Tribune, October 16...read more
  • U.S. can calm a ruffled TurkeyU.S. can calm a ruffled TurkeyThe Christian Monitor, October 17, 2007 ...read more
  • Pointless Moral Exhibitionism on TurkeyPointless Moral Exhibitionism on TurkeyRich Lowry,The National Review, October ...read more
  • Stirring up the past, jeopardizing the futureStirring up the past, jeopardizing the futureread more
  • Armenia Crime Amnesia?Armenia Crime Amnesia?Bruce Fein, The Washington Times, Oct 16...read more
  • Secretary of State PelosiSecretary of State PelosiThe Wall Street Journal, October 16, 200...read more
  • Turkey in the crosshairsTurkey in the crosshairsThe Washington Times, October 15, 2007 ...read more
  • Tawdry Genocide TaleTawdry Genocide TaleBruce Fein, Washington Times, September ...read more
  • This wasn't GenocideThis wasn't GenocideShlomo Bar-Meir, Jerusalem Post, Septemb...read more
  • Letter to Abraham H. Foxman, ADL of B'Nai B'RithLetter to Abraham H. Foxman, ADL of B'Nai B'Rithread more
  • Why America Should Build Bridges to TurkeyWhy America Should Build Bridges to TurkeyLiz Peek, July 3, 2007 The Turks are...read more
  • Statement by Professor Norman StoneStatement by Professor Norman StoneNorman Stone, August 23, 2007 I am wr...read more
  • Re: Truth and Consequences: Armenians, Turks and JewsRe: Truth and Consequences: Armenians, Turks and Jewsread more
  • Let's Unearth the Truth About what happened in 1915 togetherLet's Unearth the Truth About what happened in 1915 togetherread more
  • Turkish ambassador: "Give all sides a hearing"Turkish ambassador: "Give all sides a hearing"read more
  • Judgment Time:Should America recognize an Armenian Genocide?Judgment Time:Should America recognize an Armenian Genocide?read more
  • Norman Stone: 'There is No Armenian Genocide'Norman Stone: 'There is No Armenian Genocide'read more
  • New Scholarship Disputes Armenian New Scholarship Disputes Armenian "Genocide" Narrativeread more
  • Home
  • About US
  • Support TCA
  • Contact
  • Internships
    • TCA Washington Summer Internship Program
    • Previous Programs
  • Youth Congress
    • 2019 Youth Congress Application
    • 2018 Youth Congress
    • 2017 Youth Congress
    • 2016 Youth Congress
    • 2015 Youth Congress
    • 2014 Youth Congress
    • Turkish-Canadian Youth Congress
  • Turkish American Women’s Leadership Initiative
  • Grants
    • Turkey Study Tour Grants
    • Academic Grants
    • Public Awareness / Grassroots Grants
    • Heritage Grants
    • Humanitarian Grants
  • Issues & Information
    • U.S.-Türkiye Relations
    • PKK Terrorism
    • Türkiye and Europe
    • Armenian Issue
    • Cyprus Issue
    • Turkish History
    • Turkish Minorities Abroad
    • TCA Issue Papers
    • Reading Lists and General Resources on Türkiye
    • Suggested Links
  • Turkish American Community
    • Turkish American Appointed Officials
    • Turkish Americans Elected to Political Office
    • Elected Officials with Turkish Heritage
    • Turkish American Organizations
    • Turkish American Publications and Broadcasts
    • Turkish American Online Services
    • Prominent Turkish Americans
    • Turk Evleri
  • U.S. Congress
  • The Turkish Caucus
  • Outreach to Heritage Communities
    • African American Outreach
    • Native American Outreach
    • Hispanic American Outreach
  • Scholarships
    • Study Abroad Scholarships for American Students of Minority and Heritage Communities
    • Scholarships by Other Organizations
    • Previous TCA Programs
  • News & Events
    • News and Events
    • TCA Issue Papers
    • TCA Newsletters
  • Media
    • TCA in the News
    • Posters and Advertisements
    • Submit a Media Request
  • TAKE ACTION
  • LEGAL RIGHTS
  • CULTURE
Subscribe to Newsletter
  • Donate
  • Support the Turkish Coalition of America by Shopping at AmazonSmile
  • Turkish Coalition of America on YouTube
  • TURKISH AMERICAN LEGAL DEFENSE FUND
Turkish Coalition of America
Amerika Turk Koalisyonu
  • Boston
    P.O. Box 611
    Bedford, MA 01730
    Phone: 978.318.0047
    Fax: 978.318.0037
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  • Copyright © 2023 Turkish Coalition of America. All rights reserved.
    Site Map